Shows by day of week

• Sunday- 12
• Monday- 7
• Tuesday- 10
• Wednesday- 9
• Thursday- 9
• Friday- 15
• Saturday- 19

Shows by month

• January - 3
• February - 2
• March - 3
• April - 4
• May -
• June - 17
• July - 16
• August - 11
• September - 2
• October - 2
• November - 5
• December - 16

Shows by year

• 1994- 1
• 1995- 0
• 1996- 0
• 1997- 0
• 1998- 4
• 1999- 16
• 2000- 9
• 2001- 0
• 2002- 1
• 2003- 17
• 2004- 15
• 2009- 14
• 2010- 0
• 2011- 4
• 2012- 0
• 2013- 0
• 2014- 0
• 2015- 0
• 2016- 0
• 2017- 0
• 2018- 0
• 2019- 0
• 2020- 0
• 2021- 0
• 2022- 0
• 2023- 0
• 2024- 0
• 2025- 0
• 2026- 0

Most Frequently Played Dates

• 12/31- 3
• 12/30- 2
• 6/23- 2
• 6/24- 2
• 7/10- 2
• 7/26- 2
• 8/15- 2
• 8/9- 2
• 1/2- 1
• 1/3- 1
• 1/4- 1
• 10/30- 1
• 10/31- 1
• 11/1- 1
• 11/20- 1
• 11/21- 1
• 11/25- 1
• 11/29- 1
• 12/10- 1
• 12/11- 1
• 12/15- 1

Shows by States

• VA - 14 (17%)
• NJ - 12 (15%)
• IN - 7 (9%)
• FL - 6 (7%)
• MD - 6 (7%)
• NY - 6 (7%)
• PA - 6 (7%)
• ME - 4 (5%)
• MA - 3 (4%)
• NV - 3 (4%)
• GA - 3 (4%)
• CA - 3 (4%)
• WI - 2 (2%)
• NC - 2 (2%)
• VT - 2 (2%)
• DC - 1 (1%)
• DE - 1 (1%)

Shows by Time Zone

• Eastern - 73 (90%)
• Pacific - 6 (7%)
• Central - 2 (2%)
• Mountain - 0 (0%)

Shows by Cities

• Hampton, VA - 11 (14%)
• Camden, NJ - 8 (10%)
• Noblesville, IN - 7 (9%)
• Columbia, MD - 6 (7%)
• Philadelphia, PA - 5 (6%)
• Miami, FL - 4 (5%)
• Las Vegas, NV - 3 (4%)
• Holmdel, NJ - 3 (4%)
• Indio, CA - 3 (4%)
• Atlanta, GA - 3 (4%)
• Wantagh, NY - 3 (4%)
• Coventry, VT - 2 (2%)
• Big Cypress, FL - 2 (2%)
• Limestone, ME - 2 (2%)
• Saratoga Springs, NY - 2 (2%)
• Mansfield, MA - 2 (2%)
• Virginia Beach, VA - 2 (2%)
• East Troy, WI - 2 (2%)
• Portland, ME - 2 (2%)
• Hershey, PA - 1 (1%)
• Washington, DC - 1 (1%)
• Raleigh, NC - 1 (1%)
• Newark, DE - 1 (1%)
• Boston, MA - 1 (1%)
• East Rutherford, NJ - 1 (1%)
• Asheville, NC - 1 (1%)
• New York, NY - 1 (1%)
• Charlottesville, VA - 1 (1%)

Shows by Venues

• Hampton Coliseum - 11 (14%)
• Tweeter Center at the Waterfront - 8 (10%)
• Ruoff Music Center - 7 (9%)
• Merriweather Post Pavilion - 6 (7%)
• American Airlines Arena - 4 (5%)
• Wachovia Spectrum - 4 (5%)
• Empire Polo Club - 3 (4%)
• Jones Beach Amphitheater - 3 (4%)
• Thomas & Mack Center - 3 (4%)
• HiFi Buys Amphitheatre - 3 (4%)
• Garden State Arts Center - 3 (4%)
• Saratoga Performing Arts Center - 2 (2%)
• Loring Commerce Centre - 2 (2%)
• Newport State Airport - 2 (2%)
• GTE Virginia Beach Amphitheater - 2 (2%)
• Great Woods Center for the Performing Arts - 2 (2%)
• Big Cypress Seminole Indian Reservation - 2 (2%)
• Cumberland County Civic Center - 2 (2%)
• Alpine Valley Music Theatre - 2 (2%)
• Continental Airlines Arena - 1 (1%)
• Hersheypark Stadium - 1 (1%)
• University of Delaware - 1 (1%)
• Wachovia Center - 1 (1%)
• MCI Center - 1 (1%)
• Madison Square Garden - 1 (1%)
• John Paul Jones Arena - 1 (1%)
• ALLTEL Pavilion - 1 (1%)
• U.S. Cellular Center - 1 (1%)
• FleetCenter - 1 (1%)

Hiatus Show Breakdown

• Before hiatus - 30 (37%)
• After hiatus - 51 (63%)

291 different songs have been played (29% of songs Phish have played).
The average number of songs per show is 20.4.
The average amount of times each song was played is 5.58.
There were 92 onetimers
1660 total songs have been played in the selected shows.

There were 72 two set shows
There were 8 three set shows
There were 1 four set shows
5 songs were in a four show rotation.
22 songs were in a five show rotation.

Total Times Played

Piper - 25 (30%)
Down with Disease - 23 (28%)
Harry Hood - 22 (27%)
Run Like an Antelope - 21 (25%)
You Enjoy Myself - 21 (25%)
Cavern - 20 (24%)
Chalk Dust Torture - 20 (24%)
Wilson - 20 (24%)
Bathtub Gin - 19 (23%)
Limb By Limb - 19 (23%)
Wolfman's Brother - 19 (23%)
Birds of a Feather - 18 (22%)
Character Zero - 18 (22%)
David Bowie - 18 (22%)
Free - 18 (22%)
Mike's Song - 18 (22%)
Possum - 18 (22%)
Tweezer Reprise - 18 (22%)
Twist - 18 (22%)
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 17 (20%)
Tweezer - 17 (20%)
Weekapaug Groove - 17 (20%)
Divided Sky - 16 (19%)
Ghost - 16 (19%)
Loving Cup - 16 (19%)
Runaway Jim - 16 (19%)
Guyute - 15 (18%)
Sample in a Jar - 15 (18%)
Tube - 15 (18%)
AC/DC Bag - 14 (17%)
Back on the Train - 14 (17%)
Farmhouse - 14 (17%)
Simple - 14 (17%)
Split Open and Melt - 14 (17%)
Stash - 14 (17%)
The Moma Dance - 14 (17%)
Ya Mar - 14 (17%)
Bouncing Around the Room - 13 (16%)
NICU - 13 (16%)
Rock and Roll - 13 (16%)
Seven Below - 13 (16%)
Suzy Greenberg - 13 (16%)
The Squirming Coil - 13 (16%)
Theme from the Bottom - 13 (16%)
Water in the Sky - 13 (16%)
Gotta Jibboo - 12 (14%)
Heavy Things - 12 (14%)
Hold Your Head Up - 12 (14%)
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 11 (13%)
Golgi Apparatus - 11 (13%)
Halley's Comet - 11 (13%)
I Am Hydrogen - 11 (13%)
Julius - 11 (13%)
Lawn Boy - 11 (13%)
Punch You in the Eye - 11 (13%)
The Wedge - 11 (13%)
Prince Caspian - 10 (12%)
Reba - 10 (12%)
Slave to the Traffic Light - 10 (12%)
Taste - 10 (12%)
46 Days - 9 (11%)
Axilla - 9 (11%)
Bug - 9 (11%)
First Tube - 9 (11%)
Frankenstein - 9 (11%)
Horn - 9 (11%)
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 9 (11%)
Friday - 8 (9%)
Maze - 8 (9%)
Meatstick - 8 (9%)
Sand - 8 (9%)
Silent in the Morning - 8 (9%)
Strange Design - 8 (9%)
The Horse - 8 (9%)
Waste - 8 (9%)
Waves - 8 (9%)
When the Circus Comes - 8 (9%)
Brian and Robert - 7 (8%)
Foam - 7 (8%)
Good Times Bad Times - 7 (8%)
Jam - 7 (8%)
Kill Devil Falls - 7 (8%)
Llama - 7 (8%)
Makisupa Policeman - 7 (8%)
My Friend, My Friend - 7 (8%)
Poor Heart - 7 (8%)
Rift - 7 (8%)
Roggae - 7 (8%)
Sparkle - 7 (8%)
Walls of the Cave - 7 (8%)
All of These Dreams - 6 (7%)
Anything But Me - 6 (7%)
Backwards Down the Number Line - 6 (7%)
Contact - 6 (7%)
Dirt - 6 (7%)
Drowned - 6 (7%)
Fast Enough for You - 6 (7%)
Fluffhead - 6 (7%)
Funky Bitch - 6 (7%)
Gumbo - 6 (7%)
I Didn't Know - 6 (7%)
Mountains in the Mist - 6 (7%)
Pebbles and Marbles - 6 (7%)
Scent of a Mule - 6 (7%)
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 6 (7%)
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 6 (7%)
The Lizards - 6 (7%)
Train Song - 6 (7%)
Cars Trucks Buses - 5 (6%)
Cities - 5 (6%)
Driver - 5 (6%)
Guelah Papyrus - 5 (6%)
It's Ice - 5 (6%)
Meat - 5 (6%)
My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own - 5 (6%)
Saw It Again - 5 (6%)
Sneakin' Sally Thru the Alley - 5 (6%)
The Curtain With - 5 (6%)
The Sloth - 5 (6%)
Vultures - 5 (6%)
Army of One - 4 (4%)
Bold As Love - 4 (4%)
Buffalo Bill - 4 (4%)
Carini - 4 (4%)
Crosseyed and Painless - 4 (4%)
Dog Faced Boy - 4 (4%)
Esther - 4 (4%)
Glide - 4 (4%)
Mexican Cousin - 4 (4%)
Ocelot - 4 (4%)
Rocky Top - 4 (4%)
Roses Are Free - 4 (4%)
Secret Smile - 4 (4%)
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 4 (4%)
Time Turns Elastic - 4 (4%)
Alaska - 3 (3%)
Auld Lang Syne - 3 (3%)
Beauty of My Dreams - 3 (3%)
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 3 (3%)
Bittersweet Motel - 3 (3%)
Buried Alive - 3 (3%)
Corinna - 3 (3%)
Crowd Control - 3 (3%)
Dog Log - 3 (3%)
Dogs Stole Things - 3 (3%)
Fee - 3 (3%)
Frankie Says - 3 (3%)
Grind - 3 (3%)
Ha Ha Ha - 3 (3%)
Jesus Just Left Chicago - 3 (3%)
Joy - 3 (3%)
Light - 3 (3%)
Love You - 3 (3%)
My Soul - 3 (3%)
My Sweet One - 3 (3%)
Nellie Kane - 3 (3%)
Party Time - 3 (3%)
Sugar Shack - 3 (3%)
Terrapin - 3 (3%)
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 3 (3%)
The Mango Song - 3 (3%)
The Old Home Place - 3 (3%)
What's the Use? - 3 (3%)
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 3 (3%)
A Day in the Life - 2 (2%)
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 2 (2%)
Access Me - 2 (2%)
Albuquerque - 2 (2%)
Avenu Malkenu - 2 (2%)
Back at the Chicken Shack - 2 (2%)
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 2 (2%)
Billy Breathes - 2 (2%)
Camel Walk - 2 (2%)
Catapult - 2 (2%)
Daniel Saw the Stone - 2 (2%)
Discern - 2 (2%)
Fire - 2 (2%)
Happy Birthday to You - 2 (2%)
Jennifer Dances - 2 (2%)
Kung - 2 (2%)
Let Me Lie - 2 (2%)
Lifeboy - 2 (2%)
Lonesome Cowboy Bill - 2 (2%)
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' - 2 (2%)
On Your Way Down - 2 (2%)
Sabotage - 2 (2%)
Sanity - 2 (2%)
Show of Life - 2 (2%)
Sleep - 2 (2%)
Sleep Again - 2 (2%)
Sleeping Monkey - 2 (2%)
Sweet Virginia - 2 (2%)
Talk - 2 (2%)
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday - 2 (2%)
The Oh Kee Pa Ceremony - 2 (2%)
Thunderhead - 2 (2%)
Uncle Pen - 2 (2%)
Undermind - 2 (2%)
Walk Away - 2 (2%)
After Midnight - 1 (1%)
All Down the Line - 1 (1%)
Big Alligator - 1 (1%)
Big Ball Jam - 1 (1%)
Bill Bailey, Won't You Please Come Home? - 1 (1%)
Born to Run - 1 (1%)
Brother - 1 (1%)
Casino Boogie - 1 (1%)
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1 (1%)
Chariots of Fire - 1 (1%)
Che Hun Ta Mo - 1 (1%)
Cool Jerk - 1 (1%)
Cracklin' Rosie - 1 (1%)
Cry Baby Cry - 1 (1%)
Drums - 1 (1%)
Everyday I Have the Blues - 1 (1%)
Feel the Heat - 1 (1%)
Fikus - 1 (1%)
Gettin' Jiggy Wit' It - 1 (1%)
Ginseng Sullivan - 1 (1%)
Girls Girls Girls - 1 (1%)
Halfway to the Moon - 1 (1%)
Happy - 1 (1%)
Have Mercy - 1 (1%)
Hello My Baby - 1 (1%)
I Just Want To See His Face - 1 (1%)
I Wan'na Be Like You - 1 (1%)
If I Could - 1 (1%)
Invisible - 1 (1%)
Iron Man - 1 (1%)
Jungle Boogie - 1 (1%)
L.A. Woman - 1 (1%)
Lengthwise - 1 (1%)
Let It Loose - 1 (1%)
Light Up Or Leave Me Alone - 1 (1%)
Magilla - 1 (1%)
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 1 (1%)
Mellow Mood - 1 (1%)
Moby Dick - 1 (1%)
Mound - 1 (1%)
My Left Toe - 1 (1%)
No Quarter - 1 (1%)
Nothing - 1 (1%)
Over the Rainbow - 1 (1%)
P-Funk Medley - 1 (1%)
Purple Rain - 1 (1%)
Quadrophonic Toppling - 1 (1%)
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 1 (1%)
Ride Captain Ride - 1 (1%)
Rip This Joint - 1 (1%)
Rock Me Baby - 1 (1%)
Rock and Roll Part Two - 1 (1%)
Rocks Off - 1 (1%)
Round Room - 1 (1%)
Sexual Healing - 1 (1%)
Shafty - 1 (1%)
Shake Your Hips - 1 (1%)
She Thinks I Still Care - 1 (1%)
Shine a Light - 1 (1%)
Soul Shakedown Party - 1 (1%)
Soul Survivor - 1 (1%)
Spock's Brain - 1 (1%)
Spread It 'Round - 1 (1%)
Steam - 1 (1%)
Steep - 1 (1%)
Stop Breaking Down - 1 (1%)
Sweet Black Angel - 1 (1%)
Sweet Jane - 1 (1%)
Swept Away - 1 (1%)
Tela - 1 (1%)
Terrapin Station - 1 (1%)
The Curtain - 1 (1%)
The Dickie Scotland Song - 1 (1%)
The Little Drummer Boy - 1 (1%)
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1 (1%)
The Tears of a Clown - 1 (1%)
The Thrill is Gone - 1 (1%)
Time Loves a Hero - 1 (1%)
Torn and Frayed - 1 (1%)
Tower Jam - 1 (1%)
Tubthumping - 1 (1%)
Tumbling Dice - 1 (1%)
Turd on the Run - 1 (1%)
Twenty Years Later - 1 (1%)
Two Versions of Me - 1 (1%)
Ventilator Blues - 1 (1%)
Weigh - 1 (1%)
When the Cactus is in Bloom - 1 (1%)
Whipping Post - 1 (1%)
Windora Bug - 1 (1%)
Woodstock - 1 (1%)
You Ain't Goin' Nowhere - 1 (1%)

First Set Openers

Wilson - 8
Chalk Dust Torture - 4
AC/DC Bag - 3
Down with Disease - 3
Harry Hood - 3
Julius - 3
Llama - 3
Piper - 3
Runaway Jim - 3
Buried Alive - 2
Daniel Saw the Stone - 2
Farmhouse - 2
First Tube - 2
Kill Devil Falls - 2
Limb By Limb - 2
My Friend, My Friend - 2
Punch You in the Eye - 2
Sample in a Jar - 2
Tweezer - 2
Water in the Sky - 2
Ya Mar - 2
Access Me - 1
Back on the Train - 1
Cars Trucks Buses - 1
Crowd Control - 1
David Bowie - 1
Divided Sky - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Grind - 1
Guyute - 1
Loving Cup - 1
Meat - 1
Mike's Song - 1
Party Time - 1
Reba - 1
Rift - 1
Rock and Roll Part Two - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Sanity - 1
Seven Below - 1
Soul Shakedown Party - 1
The Moma Dance - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
The Wedge - 1
Walls of the Cave - 1

First Set Closers

Cavern - 8
Run Like an Antelope - 7
David Bowie - 6
Character Zero - 4
Split Open and Melt - 4
Taste - 4
You Enjoy Myself - 4
Bold As Love - 3
Golgi Apparatus - 2
Julius - 2
Loving Cup - 2
The Squirming Coil - 2
Time Turns Elastic - 2
AC/DC Bag - 1
After Midnight - 1
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Birds of a Feather - 1
Bittersweet Motel - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Drowned - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Fire - 1
First Tube - 1
Frankenstein - 1
If I Could - 1
Llama - 1
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 1
Mexican Cousin - 1
Pebbles and Marbles - 1
Possum - 1
Rock Me Baby - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Runaway Jim - 1
Stash - 1
Suzy Greenberg - 1
Sweet Jane - 1
The Curtain With - 1
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 1
Tube - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1
Twist - 1
Walls of the Cave - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1

Second Set Openers

Birds of a Feather - 8
Rock and Roll - 6
Down with Disease - 5
Gotta Jibboo - 5
AC/DC Bag - 4
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 4
Piper - 4
Tweezer - 4
Meatstick - 3
46 Days - 2
Backwards Down the Number Line - 2
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 2
Halley's Comet - 2
Mike's Song - 2
Punch You in the Eye - 2
Sand - 2
Seven Below - 2
Tube - 2
Twist - 2
Wolfman's Brother - 2
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 1
All of These Dreams - 1
Bathtub Gin - 1
Cavern - 1
Ghost - 1
Mellow Mood - 1
Party Time - 1
Rocks Off - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Runaway Jim - 1
Sabotage - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Stash - 1
Water in the Sky - 1
Waves - 1
Wilson - 1

Second Set Closers

Character Zero - 10
Harry Hood - 6
You Enjoy Myself - 6
Loving Cup - 5
Cavern - 4
Slave to the Traffic Light - 4
Chalk Dust Torture - 3
Suzy Greenberg - 3
Tweezer Reprise - 3
Weekapaug Groove - 3
Down with Disease - 2
Golgi Apparatus - 2
Good Times Bad Times - 2
Meatstick - 2
Possum - 2
Split Open and Melt - 2
Walls of the Cave - 2
Waste - 2
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Bittersweet Motel - 1
David Bowie - 1
Fire - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Free - 1
Ghost - 1
Hello My Baby - 1
Joy - 1
Pebbles and Marbles - 1
Prince Caspian - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 1
Simple - 1
Soul Survivor - 1
Tweezer - 1

Third Set Openers

46 Days - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Fast Enough for You - 1
Jungle Boogie - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Tweezer - 1
Twist - 1

Third Set Closers

Run Like an Antelope - 2
Slave to the Traffic Light - 2
Bug - 1
Friday - 1
Walls of the Cave - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

Fourth Set Openers

Tower Jam - 1

Fourth Set Closers

Tower Jam - 1

Encores

Tweezer Reprise - 14
Loving Cup - 6
The Squirming Coil - 6
Frankenstein - 5
Good Times Bad Times - 5
Possum - 5
Contact - 4
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 4
Bouncing Around the Room - 3
Character Zero - 3
Harry Hood - 3
Rocky Top - 3
Waste - 3
A Day in the Life - 2
Brian and Robert - 2
Bug - 2
Driver - 2
First Tube - 2
Friday - 2
Grind - 2
Lawn Boy - 2
Run Like an Antelope - 2
Secret Smile - 2
Show of Life - 2
Sleeping Monkey - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 2
Bold As Love - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Born to Run - 1
Cavern - 1
Chalk Dust Torture Reprise - 1
David Bowie - 1
Dog Log - 1
Esther - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Guyute - 1
Happy Birthday to You - 1
Hold Your Head Up - 1
Joy - 1
Julius - 1
Makisupa Policeman - 1
Mexican Cousin - 1
Moby Dick - 1
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' - 1
Ride Captain Ride - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Sabotage - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Sanity - 1
Sneakin' Sally Thru the Alley - 1
Talk - 1
Terrapin - 1
Terrapin Station - 1
The Curtain With - 1
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 1
The Mango Song - 1
The Old Home Place - 1
Tubthumping - 1
Walk Away - 1
Wolfman's Brother - 1
Woodstock - 1
Ya Mar - 1

10 20 30 40 50 most common songs that were not played in the band's history from your first year

Underplayed/Overplayed Songs since 1994

Expected versions is "percentage of shows the song was played in times number of shows seen" (eg if You Enjoy Myself were played in half of all shows and you have seen 20 shows, you would be "expected" to see 10 versions). These are the songs that you've seen the most above and below expectations. This section goes out to Amanda Wilson who inspired me to write it by seeing "Farmhouse" in each of her first 4 shows.

Underplayed

Overplayed

The 50% club

Longest Existing Gaps

Debut Count

You saw 70 song debuts
0.86 debuts per show.
The most frequently played song you have seen debuted is 46 Days (156 times).

Sort by Earliest debuted Most often played

Hiatus Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-hiatus songs that have not been seen since:

Meat - 5
Beauty of My Dreams - 3
Bittersweet Motel - 3
Dogs Stole Things - 3
My Soul - 3
Nellie Kane - 3
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 3
Avenu Malkenu - 2
Back at the Chicken Shack - 2
Billy Breathes - 2

Most frequently seen post-hiatus songs that were not seen before:

Seven Below - 13
46 Days - 9
Friday - 8
Waves - 8
Kill Devil Falls - 7
Walls of the Cave - 7
All of These Dreams - 6
Anything But Me - 6
Backwards Down the Number Line - 6
Pebbles and Marbles - 6

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the hiatus are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post hiatus

Biggest increase post hiatus

Breakup Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-breakup songs that have not been seen since:

Hold Your Head Up - 12
Friday - 8
Jam - 7
Llama - 7
Roggae - 7
Walls of the Cave - 7
Anything But Me - 6
Pebbles and Marbles - 6
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 6
Meat - 5

Most frequently seen post-breakup songs that were not seen before:

Kill Devil Falls - 7
Backwards Down the Number Line - 6
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 6
Ocelot - 4
Time Turns Elastic - 4
Alaska - 3
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 3
Grind - 3
Joy - 3
Light - 3

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the breakup are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post breakup

Biggest increase post breakup

First/Last Time Seen