Shows by day of week

• Sunday- 16
• Monday- 2
• Tuesday- 5
• Wednesday- 7
• Thursday- 3
• Friday- 17
• Saturday- 20

Shows by month

• January - 3
• February - 1
• March -
• April -
• May -
• June - 8
• July - 16
• August - 20
• September - 10
• October - 2
• November - 2
• December - 8

Shows by year

• 1993- 1
• 1994- 1
• 1995- 1
• 1996- 1
• 1997- 0
• 1998- 0
• 1999- 0
• 2000- 0
• 2001- 0
• 2002- 0
• 2003- 3
• 2004- 0
• 2009- 5
• 2010- 2
• 2011- 3
• 2012- 4
• 2013- 2
• 2014- 1
• 2015- 6
• 2016- 3
• 2017- 6
• 2018- 5
• 2019- 0
• 2020- 0
• 2021- 11
• 2022- 3
• 2023- 7
• 2024- 0
• 2025- 5

Most Frequently Played Dates

• 12/31- 3
• 7/16- 3
• 8/4- 3
• 8/5- 3
• 12/28- 2
• 12/29- 2
• 6/15- 2
• 6/17- 2
• 7/15- 2
• 8/14- 2
• 8/15- 2
• 8/6- 2
• 9/4- 2
• 9/5- 2
• 1/1- 1
• 1/2- 1
• 1/3- 1
• 10/16- 1
• 10/21- 1
• 11/16- 1
• 11/2- 1

Shows by States

• FL - 16 (23%)
• GA - 13 (19%)
• CO - 9 (13%)
• NJ - 9 (13%)
• NY - 8 (11%)
• WA - 5 (7%)
• SC - 3 (4%)
• NC - 3 (4%)
• WI - 2 (3%)
• MA - 1 (1%)
• OH - 1 (1%)

Shows by Time Zone

• Eastern - 54 (77%)
• Mountain - 9 (13%)
• Pacific - 5 (7%)
• Central - 2 (3%)

Shows by Cities

• Alpharetta, GA - 13 (19%)
• Miami, FL - 11 (16%)
• Atlantic City, NJ - 9 (13%)
• Commerce City, CO - 9 (13%)
• New York, NY - 8 (11%)
• George, WA - 5 (7%)
• North Charleston, SC - 3 (4%)
• Wilmington, NC - 2 (3%)
• West Palm Beach, FL - 2 (3%)
• East Troy, WI - 2 (3%)
• Jacksonville, FL - 1 (1%)
• Gainesville, FL - 1 (1%)
• Sunrise, FL - 1 (1%)
• Mansfield, MA - 1 (1%)
• Charlotte, NC - 1 (1%)
• Cuyahoga Falls, OH - 1 (1%)

Shows by Venues

• Verizon Wireless Amphitheatre at Encore Park - 13 (19%)
• American Airlines Arena - 11 (16%)
• Dick's Sporting Goods Park - 9 (13%)
• Madison Square Garden - 8 (11%)
• Atlantic City Beach - 6 (9%)
• Gorge Amphitheatre - 5 (7%)
• North Charleston Coliseum - 3 (4%)
• Bader Field - 3 (4%)
• Live Oak Bank Pavilion at Riverfront Park - 2 (3%)
• Alpine Valley Music Theatre - 2 (3%)
• Verizon Wireless Amphitheatre - Charlotte - 1 (1%)
• West Palm Beach Auditorium - 1 (1%)
• Great Woods Center for the Performing Arts - 1 (1%)
• Coral Sky Amphitheater - 1 (1%)
• Blossom Music Center - 1 (1%)
• Jacksonville Veterans Memorial Arena - 1 (1%)
• Sunrise Musical Theatre - 1 (1%)
• Florida Theatre - 1 (1%)

Hiatus Show Breakdown

• Before hiatus - 4 (6%)
• After hiatus - 66 (94%)

325 different songs have been played (32% of songs Phish have played).
The average number of songs per show is 20.6.
The average amount of times each song was played is 4.36.
There were 98 onetimers
1443 total songs have been played in the selected shows.

There were 67 two set shows
There were 3 three set shows
2 songs were in a four show rotation.
14 songs were in a five show rotation.

Total Times Played

Harry Hood - 19 (27%)
Chalk Dust Torture - 18 (25%)
Mike's Song - 17 (24%)
Run Like an Antelope - 17 (24%)
Tweezer - 17 (24%)
Tweezer Reprise - 17 (24%)
Weekapaug Groove - 17 (24%)
Ghost - 16 (22%)
Bathtub Gin - 15 (21%)
Sand - 15 (21%)
Slave to the Traffic Light - 15 (21%)
The Moma Dance - 15 (21%)
Piper - 14 (20%)
Tube - 14 (20%)
Cavern - 13 (18%)
Free - 13 (18%)
Possum - 13 (18%)
Simple - 13 (18%)
Wolfman's Brother - 13 (18%)
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 12 (17%)
Back on the Train - 12 (17%)
Backwards Down the Number Line - 12 (17%)
Character Zero - 12 (17%)
Divided Sky - 12 (17%)
Suzy Greenberg - 12 (17%)
Bouncing Around the Room - 11 (15%)
Carini - 11 (15%)
Down with Disease - 11 (15%)
First Tube - 11 (15%)
Prince Caspian - 11 (15%)
Reba - 11 (15%)
Stash - 11 (15%)
Wilson - 11 (15%)
46 Days - 10 (14%)
David Bowie - 10 (14%)
Fluffhead - 10 (14%)
Golgi Apparatus - 10 (14%)
Lawn Boy - 10 (14%)
Maze - 10 (14%)
Runaway Jim - 10 (14%)
You Enjoy Myself - 10 (14%)
555 - 9 (12%)
Blaze On - 9 (12%)
Gotta Jibboo - 9 (12%)
Hold Your Head Up - 9 (12%)
I Am Hydrogen - 9 (12%)
Light - 9 (12%)
NICU - 9 (12%)
Rift - 9 (12%)
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9 (12%)
AC/DC Bag - 8 (11%)
Bug - 8 (11%)
Crosseyed and Painless - 8 (11%)
Foam - 8 (11%)
Funky Bitch - 8 (11%)
Kill Devil Falls - 8 (11%)
Loving Cup - 8 (11%)
Meatstick - 8 (11%)
No Men In No Man's Land - 8 (11%)
Ocelot - 8 (11%)
Set Your Soul Free - 8 (11%)
Silent in the Morning - 8 (11%)
Sleeping Monkey - 8 (11%)
Steam - 8 (11%)
The Wedge - 8 (11%)
Theme From the Bottom - 8 (11%)
Undermind - 8 (11%)
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 7 (10%)
Everything's Right - 7 (10%)
Horn - 7 (10%)
More - 7 (10%)
Rock and Roll - 7 (10%)
Sample in a Jar - 7 (10%)
Scent of a Mule - 7 (10%)
The Squirming Coil - 7 (10%)
Twist - 7 (10%)
Water in the Sky - 7 (10%)
What's the Use? - 7 (10%)
A Day in the Life - 6 (8%)
A Life Beyond The Dream - 6 (8%)
Drift While You're Sleeping - 6 (8%)
Gumbo - 6 (8%)
Julius - 6 (8%)
Llama - 6 (8%)
Martian Monster - 6 (8%)
Mercury - 6 (8%)
Poor Heart - 6 (8%)
Roggae - 6 (8%)
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 6 (8%)
The Horse - 6 (8%)
Walls of the Cave - 6 (8%)
Ya Mar - 6 (8%)
Alaska - 5 (7%)
Birds of a Feather - 5 (7%)
Buried Alive - 5 (7%)
Fuego - 5 (7%)
Golden Age - 5 (7%)
Good Times Bad Times - 5 (7%)
Heavy Things - 5 (7%)
Joy - 5 (7%)
Limb By Limb - 5 (7%)
My Friend, My Friend - 5 (7%)
Plasma - 5 (7%)
Punch You in the Eye - 5 (7%)
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 5 (7%)
Seven Below - 5 (7%)
Shade - 5 (7%)
Sneakin' Sally Through the Alley - 5 (7%)
Sparkle - 5 (7%)
Split Open and Melt - 5 (7%)
Taste - 5 (7%)
The Lizards - 5 (7%)
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 5 (7%)
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 5 (7%)
Waste - 5 (7%)
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 4 (5%)
Camel Walk - 4 (5%)
Cities - 4 (5%)
Destiny Unbound - 4 (5%)
Drowned - 4 (5%)
Farmhouse - 4 (5%)
Fee - 4 (5%)
Frankenstein - 4 (5%)
Guyute - 4 (5%)
Halfway to the Moon - 4 (5%)
It's Ice - 4 (5%)
Makisupa Policeman - 4 (5%)
My Soul - 4 (5%)
Party Time - 4 (5%)
Rocky Top - 4 (5%)
Roses Are Free - 4 (5%)
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 4 (5%)
Soul Planet - 4 (5%)
The Line - 4 (5%)
The Sloth - 4 (5%)
Wingsuit - 4 (5%)
Winterqueen - 4 (5%)
Auld Lang Syne - 3 (4%)
Axilla - 3 (4%)
Axilla (Part II) - 3 (4%)
Beneath a Sea of Stars Part 1 - 3 (4%)
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 3 (4%)
Cars Trucks Buses - 3 (4%)
Devotion To a Dream - 3 (4%)
Esther - 3 (4%)
Fuck Your Face - 3 (4%)
Ha Ha Ha - 3 (4%)
Halley's Comet - 3 (4%)
Hey Stranger - 3 (4%)
I Didn't Know - 3 (4%)
Lifeboy - 3 (4%)
Love You - 3 (4%)
Mound - 3 (4%)
Mountains in the Mist - 3 (4%)
Nellie Kane - 3 (4%)
Rise/Come Together - 3 (4%)
Ruby Waves - 3 (4%)
Saw It Again - 3 (4%)
Shine a Light - 3 (4%)
Sigma Oasis - 3 (4%)
Soul Shakedown Party - 3 (4%)
Turtle in the Clouds - 3 (4%)
Twenty Years Later - 3 (4%)
Uncle Pen - 3 (4%)
Waiting All Night - 3 (4%)
When the Circus Comes - 3 (4%)
Yarmouth Road - 3 (4%)
A Wave of Hope - 2 (2%)
About to Run - 2 (2%)
All of These Dreams - 2 (2%)
Alumni Blues - 2 (2%)
Amazing Grace - 2 (2%)
Army of One - 2 (2%)
Ass Handed - 2 (2%)
Bike - 2 (2%)
Billy Breathes - 2 (2%)
Bold As Love - 2 (2%)
Colonel Forbin's Ascent - 2 (2%)
Contact - 2 (2%)
Corinna - 2 (2%)
Dem Bones - 2 (2%)
Dinner and a Movie - 2 (2%)
Dirt - 2 (2%)
Dogs Stole Things - 2 (2%)
Driver - 2 (2%)
Fast Enough for You - 2 (2%)
Fly Famous Mockingbird - 2 (2%)
Frost - 2 (2%)
Ginseng Sullivan - 2 (2%)
Harpua - 2 (2%)
Home - 2 (2%)
I Always Wanted It This Way - 2 (2%)
I Am the Walrus - 2 (2%)
I Been Around - 2 (2%)
Jam - 2 (2%)
Jesus Just Left Chicago - 2 (2%)
Leaves - 2 (2%)
Letter to Jimmy Page - 2 (2%)
Lonely Trip - 2 (2%)
Meat - 2 (2%)
Monsters - 2 (2%)
Most Events Aren't Planned - 2 (2%)
NO2 - 2 (2%)
Oblivion - 2 (2%)
Pebbles and Marbles - 2 (2%)
Petrichor - 2 (2%)
Steep - 2 (2%)
Sweet Adeline - 2 (2%)
Swept Away - 2 (2%)
Tela - 2 (2%)
The Birdwatcher - 2 (2%)
The Curtain - 2 (2%)
The Curtain With - 2 (2%)
The Dogs - 2 (2%)
The Final Hurrah - 2 (2%)
The Howling - 2 (2%)
The Landlady - 2 (2%)
The Mango Song - 2 (2%)
The Oh Kee Pa Ceremony - 2 (2%)
The Old Home Place - 2 (2%)
The Well - 2 (2%)
Things People Do - 2 (2%)
Thread - 2 (2%)
Train Song - 2 (2%)
Vultures - 2 (2%)
Walk Away - 2 (2%)
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 2 (2%)
...And Flew Away - 1 (1%)
Access Me - 1 (1%)
After Midnight - 1 (1%)
Anything But Me - 1 (1%)
Back in the Bubble - 1 (1%)
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 1 (1%)
Big Ball Jam - 1 (1%)
Bittersweet Motel - 1 (1%)
Bliss - 1 (1%)
Blue Moon - 1 (1%)
Brian and Robert - 1 (1%)
Brother - 1 (1%)
Brown Eyed Girl - 1 (1%)
Carolina - 1 (1%)
Casual Enlightenment - 1 (1%)
Catapult - 1 (1%)
Chocolate Rain - 1 (1%)
Cinnamon Girl - 1 (1%)
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1 (1%)
Cool It Down - 1 (1%)
Crazy Sometimes - 1 (1%)
Demand - 1 (1%)
Dixie Cannonball - 1 (1%)
Dog Faced Boy - 1 (1%)
Energy - 1 (1%)
Everything In Its Right Place - 1 (1%)
Feel the Heat - 1 (1%)
Fire - 1 (1%)
Foreplay/Long Time - 1 (1%)
Frankie Says - 1 (1%)
Friday - 1 (1%)
Gone - 1 (1%)
Guelah Papyrus - 1 (1%)
Guy Forget - 1 (1%)
Happy Birthday to You - 1 (1%)
Have Mercy - 1 (1%)
Heartbreaker - 1 (1%)
Heavy Rotation - 1 (1%)
How Many People Are You - 1 (1%)
I Never Needed You Like This Before - 1 (1%)
Icculus - 1 (1%)
If I Could - 1 (1%)
If I Only Had a Brain - 1 (1%)
In The Good Old Summer Time - 1 (1%)
Iron Man - 1 (1%)
Izabella - 1 (1%)
Johnny B. Goode - 1 (1%)
Jungle Boogie - 1 (1%)
Keeping It Real - 1 (1%)
Keyboard Army - 1 (1%)
Kung - 1 (1%)
Lengthwise - 1 (1%)
Let Me Lie - 1 (1%)
Light Up Or Leave Me Alone - 1 (1%)
Manteca - 1 (1%)
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 1 (1%)
Mellow Mood - 1 (1%)
Mercy - 1 (1%)
Miss You - 1 (1%)
Moonage Daydream - 1 (1%)
Mr. Completely - 1 (1%)
Mull - 1 (1%)
My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own - 1 (1%)
My Sweet One - 1 (1%)
No Quarter - 1 (1%)
Nothing - 1 (1%)
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' - 1 (1%)
Olivia's Pool - 1 (1%)
On Your Way Down - 1 (1%)
On the Road Again - 1 (1%)
Once in a Lifetime - 1 (1%)
Paul and Silas - 1 (1%)
Peaches en Regalia - 1 (1%)
Sanity - 1 (1%)
See That My Grave Is Kept Clean - 1 (1%)
Sightless Escape - 1 (1%)
Sleep Again - 1 (1%)
Space Oddity - 1 (1%)
Spanish Moon - 1 (1%)
Starman - 1 (1%)
Sugar Shack - 1 (1%)
Sunshine of Your Feeling - 1 (1%)
Sweet Virginia - 1 (1%)
Terrapin - 1 (1%)
The Ballad of Curtis Loew - 1 (1%)
The Birds - 1 (1%)
The Connection - 1 (1%)
The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia - 1 (1%)
The Wind Cries Mary - 1 (1%)
Tide Turns - 1 (1%)
Torn and Frayed - 1 (1%)
United We Stand - 1 (1%)
Waking Up Dead - 1 (1%)
Waves - 1 (1%)
Weigh - 1 (1%)
Wombat - 1 (1%)
You Sexy Thing - 1 (1%)
Your Pet Cat - 1 (1%)

First Set Openers

Buried Alive - 5
Cars Trucks Buses - 3
Free - 3
Kill Devil Falls - 3
Runaway Jim - 3
Sample in a Jar - 3
Tube - 3
46 Days - 2
Golgi Apparatus - 2
Llama - 2
Mike's Song - 2
Sand - 2
Soul Shakedown Party - 2
The Landlady - 2
The Moma Dance - 2
Tweezer - 2
Wolfman's Brother - 2
AC/DC Bag - 1
Alumni Blues - 1
Bouncing Around the Room - 1
Brother - 1
Carini - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Chocolate Rain - 1
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1
David Bowie - 1
Dinner and a Movie - 1
Dogs Stole Things - 1
Fee - 1
First Tube - 1
Happy Birthday to You - 1
Loving Cup - 1
Maze - 1
No Men In No Man's Land - 1
Paul and Silas - 1
Piper - 1
See That My Grave Is Kept Clean - 1
Soul Planet - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
The Curtain With - 1
The Sloth - 1
Torn and Frayed - 1
Wilson - 1
Ya Mar - 1

First Set Closers

Run Like an Antelope - 8
Bathtub Gin - 6
Character Zero - 5
Cavern - 4
David Bowie - 4
The Squirming Coil - 4
Drift While You're Sleeping - 3
Walls of the Cave - 3
Carini - 2
Golgi Apparatus - 2
Prince Caspian - 2
Sand - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 1
Blaze On - 1
First Tube - 1
Frankenstein - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
I Am the Walrus - 1
Izabella - 1
Johnny B. Goode - 1
Julius - 1
Meatstick - 1
Moonage Daydream - 1
More - 1
Mound - 1
Plasma - 1
Possum - 1
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 1
Split Open and Melt - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
Taste - 1
Tube - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

Second Set Openers

Mike's Song - 6
Crosseyed and Painless - 5
Set Your Soul Free - 4
Carini - 3
Ghost - 3
Rock and Roll - 3
Blaze On - 2
Chalk Dust Torture - 2
Drowned - 2
No Men In No Man's Land - 2
Sand - 2
Tweezer - 2
46 Days - 1
A Day in the Life - 1
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 1
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Axilla (Part II) - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Birds of a Feather - 1
Dem Bones - 1
Everything's Right - 1
Golden Age - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Have Mercy - 1
I Never Needed You Like This Before - 1
Kill Devil Falls - 1
Llama - 1
More - 1
Mound - 1
Mr. Completely - 1
My Soul - 1
Oblivion - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Rift - 1
Rise/Come Together - 1
Seven Below - 1
Sigma Oasis - 1
Simple - 1
Stash - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
The Curtain - 1
The Sloth - 1
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 1
Twist - 1
Wilson - 1
Wolfman's Brother - 1

Second Set Closers

Slave to the Traffic Light - 9
Harry Hood - 6
Run Like an Antelope - 5
Suzy Greenberg - 5
Character Zero - 4
First Tube - 3
Rock and Roll - 3
You Enjoy Myself - 3
Bug - 2
More - 2
Possum - 2
Walls of the Cave - 2
Weekapaug Groove - 2
Cavern - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
David Bowie - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Good Times Bad Times - 1
I Always Wanted It This Way - 1
I Am the Walrus - 1
In The Good Old Summer Time - 1
Kung - 1
Light - 1
Llama - 1
Loving Cup - 1
Martian Monster - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 1
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 1
Shine a Light - 1
Sweet Adeline - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 1

Third Set Openers

Dem Bones - 1
Jungle Boogie - 1
Party Time - 1

Third Set Closers

Julius - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

Encores

Tweezer Reprise - 15
Sleeping Monkey - 7
Loving Cup - 6
First Tube - 5
Hold Your Head Up - 5
A Life Beyond The Dream - 4
Cavern - 4
Good Times Bad Times - 4
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 4
Frankenstein - 3
Harry Hood - 3
Meatstick - 3
More - 3
A Day in the Life - 2
Fluffhead - 2
Funky Bitch - 2
Joy - 2
Julius - 2
Rocky Top - 2
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 2
The Squirming Coil - 2
Waste - 2
Wilson - 2
About to Run - 1
After Midnight - 1
Amazing Grace - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 1
Bike - 1
Bittersweet Motel - 1
Blue Moon - 1
Bold As Love - 1
Brown Eyed Girl - 1
Carolina - 1
Character Zero - 1
Cinnamon Girl - 1
Contact - 1
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1
Fee - 1
Foreplay/Long Time - 1
Free - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Harpua - 1
Heavy Things - 1
If I Could - 1
Keyboard Army - 1
Lawn Boy - 1
Love You - 1
Makisupa Policeman - 1
Martian Monster - 1
Monsters - 1
NO2 - 1
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' - 1
On the Road Again - 1
Once in a Lifetime - 1
Possum - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Shine a Light - 1
Silent in the Morning - 1
Space Oddity - 1
Suzy Greenberg - 1
Sweet Adeline - 1
The Ballad of Curtis Loew - 1
The Horse - 1
The Howling - 1
The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia - 1
The Wind Cries Mary - 1
Turtle in the Clouds - 1
United We Stand - 1
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1
When the Circus Comes - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1
Your Pet Cat - 1

10 20 30 40 50 most common songs that were not played in the band's history from your first year

Underplayed/Overplayed Songs since 1993

Expected versions is "percentage of shows the song was played in times number of shows seen" (eg if You Enjoy Myself were played in half of all shows and you have seen 20 shows, you would be "expected" to see 10 versions). These are the songs that you've seen the most above and below expectations. This section goes out to Amanda Wilson who inspired me to write it by seeing "Farmhouse" in each of her first 4 shows.

Underplayed

Overplayed

The 50% club

Longest Existing Gaps

Debut Count

You saw 24 song debuts
0.34 debuts per show.
The most frequently played song you have seen debuted is Most Events Aren't Planned (21 times).

Sort by Earliest debuted Most often played

Hiatus Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-hiatus songs that have not been seen since:

Amazing Grace - 2
Sweet Adeline - 2
The Curtain - 2
Big Ball Jam - 1
Brown Eyed Girl - 1
Dog Faced Boy - 1
Foreplay/Long Time - 1
Guelah Papyrus - 1
If I Only Had a Brain - 1
Johnny B. Goode - 1

Most frequently seen post-hiatus songs that were not seen before:

Chalk Dust Torture - 18
Tweezer - 17
Tweezer Reprise - 17
Ghost - 16
Bathtub Gin - 15
Sand - 15
The Moma Dance - 15
Piper - 14
Tube - 14
Wolfman's Brother - 13

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the hiatus are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post hiatus

Biggest increase post hiatus

Breakup Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-breakup songs that have not been seen since:

Amazing Grace - 2
Jam - 2
Sweet Adeline - 2
The Curtain - 2
Anything But Me - 1
Big Ball Jam - 1
Brown Eyed Girl - 1
Dog Faced Boy - 1
Feel the Heat - 1
Foreplay/Long Time - 1

Most frequently seen post-breakup songs that were not seen before:

Bathtub Gin - 15
Sand - 15
Back on the Train - 12
Backwards Down the Number Line - 12
Character Zero - 12
Carini - 11
Prince Caspian - 11
46 Days - 10
Fluffhead - 10
555 - 9

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the breakup are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post breakup

Biggest increase post breakup

First/Last Time Seen