Shows by day of week

• Sunday- 8
• Monday- 3
• Tuesday- 8
• Wednesday- 9
• Thursday- 8
• Friday- 21
• Saturday- 17

Shows by month

• January - 3
• February -
• March -
• April - 3
• May - 1
• June - 9
• July - 12
• August - 9
• September -
• October - 8
• November - 5
• December - 24

Shows by year

• 1997- 1
• 1998- 5
• 1999- 2
• 2000- 2
• 2001- 0
• 2002- 0
• 2003- 3
• 2004- 2
• 2009- 8
• 2010- 10
• 2011- 7
• 2012- 5
• 2013- 6
• 2014- 3
• 2015- 2
• 2016- 3
• 2017- 2
• 2018- 2
• 2019- 3
• 2020- 0
• 2021- 0
• 2022- 1
• 2023- 2
• 2024- 1
• 2025- 2
• 2026- 2

Most Frequently Played Dates

• 12/30- 8
• 12/31- 5
• 12/28- 4
• 12/29- 3
• 1/1- 2
• 10/27- 2
• 10/31- 2
• 12/2- 2
• 7/12- 2
• 8/14- 2
• 1/2- 1
• 10/16- 1
• 10/22- 1
• 10/29- 1
• 10/30- 1
• 11/24- 1
• 11/25- 1
• 11/26- 1
• 11/27- 1
• 11/28- 1
• 12/3- 1

Shows by States

• NY - 49 (66%)
• NJ - 6 (8%)
• CT - 5 (7%)
• MA - 4 (5%)
• NV - 3 (4%)
• RI - 2 (3%)
• PA - 2 (3%)
• ME - 2 (3%)
• VT - 1 (1%)

Shows by Time Zone

• Eastern - 71 (96%)
• Pacific - 3 (4%)
• Mountain - 0 (0%)
• Central - 0 (0%)

Shows by Cities

• New York, NY - 29 (39%)
• Saratoga Springs, NY - 7 (9%)
• Wantagh, NY - 7 (9%)
• Hartford, CT - 5 (7%)
• Atlantic City, NJ - 3 (4%)
• Albany, NY - 3 (4%)
• Las Vegas, NV - 3 (4%)
• Volney, NY - 2 (3%)
• Limestone, ME - 2 (3%)
• Worcester, MA - 2 (3%)
• Camden, NJ - 2 (3%)
• Providence, RI - 2 (3%)
• Hershey, PA - 1 (1%)
• Coventry, VT - 1 (1%)
• Boston, MA - 1 (1%)
• Mansfield, MA - 1 (1%)
• Philadelphia, PA - 1 (1%)
• Holmdel, NJ - 1 (1%)
• Uniondale, NY - 1 (1%)

Shows by Venues

• Madison Square Garden - 27 (36%)
• Saratoga Performing Arts Center - 7 (9%)
• Jones Beach Amphitheater - 7 (9%)
• The Comcast Theatre - 3 (4%)
• Boardwalk Hall - 3 (4%)
• Loring Commerce Centre - 2 (3%)
• Providence Civic Center - 2 (3%)
• Tweeter Center at the Waterfront - 2 (3%)
• Pepsi Arena - 2 (3%)
• Oswego County Airport - 2 (3%)
• Randall's Island - 2 (3%)
• Worcester Centrum Centre - 2 (3%)
• Sphere - 2 (3%)
• Hartford Civic Center - 2 (3%)
• Newport State Airport - 1 (1%)
• Hersheypark Stadium - 1 (1%)
• Knickerbocker Arena - 1 (1%)
• Wachovia Center - 1 (1%)
• MGM Grand Garden Arena - 1 (1%)
• Great Woods Center for the Performing Arts - 1 (1%)
• Garden State Arts Center - 1 (1%)
• FleetCenter - 1 (1%)
• Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum - 1 (1%)

Hiatus Show Breakdown

• Before hiatus - 10 (14%)
• After hiatus - 64 (86%)

326 different songs have been played (32% of songs Phish have played).
The average number of songs per show is 21.4.
The average amount of times each song was played is 4.79.
There were 122 onetimers
1587 total songs have been played in the selected shows.

There were 63 two set shows
There were 10 three set shows
There were 1 four set shows
10 songs were in a four show rotation.
28 songs were in a five show rotation.

Total Times Played

Down with Disease - 23 (31%)
Tweezer Reprise - 23 (31%)
Tweezer - 22 (29%)
Chalk Dust Torture - 19 (25%)
David Bowie - 19 (25%)
Ghost - 19 (25%)
Harry Hood - 19 (25%)
Piper - 19 (25%)
Rock and Roll - 19 (25%)
Weekapaug Groove - 19 (25%)
Character Zero - 17 (22%)
Mike's Song - 17 (22%)
Tube - 17 (22%)
Wilson - 17 (22%)
You Enjoy Myself - 17 (22%)
Punch You in the Eye - 16 (21%)
Reba - 16 (21%)
Run Like an Antelope - 16 (21%)
The Moma Dance - 16 (21%)
46 Days - 15 (20%)
AC/DC Bag - 15 (20%)
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 15 (20%)
Bathtub Gin - 15 (20%)
Fluffhead - 15 (20%)
Free - 15 (20%)
Kill Devil Falls - 15 (20%)
Slave to the Traffic Light - 15 (20%)
The Wedge - 15 (20%)
Birds of a Feather - 14 (18%)
Cavern - 14 (18%)
Ocelot - 14 (18%)
Possum - 14 (18%)
Sample in a Jar - 14 (18%)
Twist - 14 (18%)
Wolfman's Brother - 14 (18%)
Cities - 13 (17%)
Golgi Apparatus - 13 (17%)
Axilla - 12 (16%)
Backwards Down the Number Line - 12 (16%)
First Tube - 12 (16%)
Halley's Comet - 12 (16%)
Julius - 12 (16%)
NICU - 12 (16%)
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 11 (14%)
Bouncing Around the Room - 11 (14%)
Carini - 11 (14%)
Lawn Boy - 11 (14%)
Light - 11 (14%)
Runaway Jim - 11 (14%)
Sand - 11 (14%)
Suzy Greenberg - 11 (14%)
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 11 (14%)
Walls of the Cave - 11 (14%)
Back on the Train - 10 (13%)
Gotta Jibboo - 10 (13%)
Guyute - 10 (13%)
Loving Cup - 10 (13%)
Maze - 10 (13%)
Prince Caspian - 10 (13%)
Silent in the Morning - 10 (13%)
Stash - 10 (13%)
Funky Bitch - 9 (12%)
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9 (12%)
The Horse - 9 (12%)
Bug - 8 (10%)
Divided Sky - 8 (10%)
Heavy Things - 8 (10%)
Limb By Limb - 8 (10%)
My Friend, My Friend - 8 (10%)
Show of Life - 8 (10%)
Simple - 8 (10%)
Theme from the Bottom - 8 (10%)
Ya Mar - 8 (10%)
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 7 (9%)
Golden Age - 7 (9%)
Gumbo - 7 (9%)
I Am Hydrogen - 7 (9%)
Rift - 7 (9%)
Split Open and Melt - 7 (9%)
Timber (Jerry the Mule) - 7 (9%)
Dirt - 6 (8%)
Farmhouse - 6 (8%)
Guelah Papyrus - 6 (8%)
My Soul - 6 (8%)
Poor Heart - 6 (8%)
Scent of a Mule - 6 (8%)
Sneakin' Sally Thru the Alley - 6 (8%)
Sparkle - 6 (8%)
Steam - 6 (8%)
Sugar Shack - 6 (8%)
The Squirming Coil - 6 (8%)
Twenty Years Later - 6 (8%)
Water in the Sky - 6 (8%)
Auld Lang Syne - 5 (6%)
Fuego - 5 (6%)
Good Times Bad Times - 5 (6%)
Halfway to the Moon - 5 (6%)
I Didn't Know - 5 (6%)
Joy - 5 (6%)
Martian Monster - 5 (6%)
Roggae - 5 (6%)
Roses Are Free - 5 (6%)
Seven Below - 5 (6%)
Sleeping Monkey - 5 (6%)
Taste - 5 (6%)
Walk Away - 5 (6%)
Waste - 5 (6%)
555 - 4 (5%)
Army of One - 4 (5%)
Beauty of My Dreams - 4 (5%)
Buried Alive - 4 (5%)
Camel Walk - 4 (5%)
Crosseyed and Painless - 4 (5%)
Driver - 4 (5%)
Drowned - 4 (5%)
Everything's Right - 4 (5%)
Foam - 4 (5%)
Frankenstein - 4 (5%)
Grind - 4 (5%)
Horn - 4 (5%)
Llama - 4 (5%)
Meatstick - 4 (5%)
Mound - 4 (5%)
Mountains in the Mist - 4 (5%)
My Sweet One - 4 (5%)
Nellie Kane - 4 (5%)
No Men In No Man's Land - 4 (5%)
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 4 (5%)
Saw It Again - 4 (5%)
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 4 (5%)
Steep - 4 (5%)
Swept Away - 4 (5%)
The Lizards - 4 (5%)
The Old Home Place - 4 (5%)
The Sloth - 4 (5%)
Vultures - 4 (5%)
Waves - 4 (5%)
A Day in the Life - 3 (4%)
Alaska - 3 (4%)
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars - 3 (4%)
Blaze On - 3 (4%)
Brother - 3 (4%)
Devotion to a Dream - 3 (4%)
Fee - 3 (4%)
Glide - 3 (4%)
Icculus - 3 (4%)
It's Ice - 3 (4%)
McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters - 3 (4%)
Meat - 3 (4%)
More - 3 (4%)
Plasma - 3 (4%)
Rocky Top - 3 (4%)
Set Your Soul Free - 3 (4%)
The Mango Song - 3 (4%)
Waiting All Night - 3 (4%)
When the Circus Comes - 3 (4%)
Wingsuit - 3 (4%)
Yarmouth Road - 3 (4%)
A Life Beyond The Dream - 2 (2%)
A Wave of Hope - 2 (2%)
About to Run - 2 (2%)
Bold As Love - 2 (2%)
Catapult - 2 (2%)
Colonel Forbin's Ascent - 2 (2%)
Contact - 2 (2%)
Corinna - 2 (2%)
Crowd Control - 2 (2%)
Daniel Saw the Stone - 2 (2%)
Dog Log - 2 (2%)
Dogs Stole Things - 2 (2%)
Drift While You're Sleeping - 2 (2%)
Evolve - 2 (2%)
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 2 (2%)
Fly Famous Mockingbird - 2 (2%)
Fuck Your Face - 2 (2%)
Ginseng Sullivan - 2 (2%)
Ha Ha Ha - 2 (2%)
If I Could - 2 (2%)
Jam - 2 (2%)
Kung - 2 (2%)
Leaves - 2 (2%)
Lifeboy - 2 (2%)
Makisupa Policeman - 2 (2%)
Party Time - 2 (2%)
Pebbles and Marbles - 2 (2%)
Pillow Jets - 2 (2%)
Ruby Waves - 2 (2%)
Sanity - 2 (2%)
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 2 (2%)
Shade - 2 (2%)
Shine a Light - 2 (2%)
Sleep - 2 (2%)
The Ballad of Curtis Loew - 2 (2%)
The Curtain With - 2 (2%)
The Dogs - 2 (2%)
The Final Hurrah - 2 (2%)
The Line - 2 (2%)
The Star-Spangled Banner - 2 (2%)
Time Turns Elastic - 2 (2%)
Train Song - 2 (2%)
Undermind - 2 (2%)
We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains - 2 (2%)
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 2 (2%)
Your Pet Cat - 2 (2%)
A Apolitical Blues - 1 (1%)
Access Me - 1 (1%)
After Midnight - 1 (1%)
Albuquerque - 1 (1%)
All That You Dream - 1 (1%)
All of These Dreams - 1 (1%)
Alumni Blues - 1 (1%)
Anything But Me - 1 (1%)
Ass Handed - 1 (1%)
Avenu Malkenu - 1 (1%)
Beauty of a Broken Heart - 1 (1%)
Been Caught Stealing - 1 (1%)
Beneath a Sea of Stars Part 1 - 1 (1%)
Billy Breathes - 1 (1%)
Bittersweet Motel - 1 (1%)
Brian and Robert - 1 (1%)
Buffalo Bill - 1 (1%)
Burn That Bridge - 1 (1%)
Can't Always Listen - 1 (1%)
Carolina - 1 (1%)
Cars Trucks Buses - 1 (1%)
Cathy's Clown - 1 (1%)
Chariots of Fire - 1 (1%)
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1 (1%)
Crazy Sometimes - 1 (1%)
Crossroads - 1 (1%)
Day or Night - 1 (1%)
Destiny Unbound - 1 (1%)
Dinner and a Movie - 1 (1%)
Discern - 1 (1%)
Dixie Chicken - 1 (1%)
Don't Bogart That Joint - 1 (1%)
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1 (1%)
Fire - 1 (1%)
Fly Like an Eagle - 1 (1%)
Free Bird - 1 (1%)
Friday - 1 (1%)
Garden Party - 1 (1%)
Gone - 1 (1%)
Happy Birthday to You - 1 (1%)
Have Mercy - 1 (1%)
Head Held High - 1 (1%)
Heartbreaker - 1 (1%)
Hey Stranger - 1 (1%)
Hold Your Head Up - 1 (1%)
Home - 1 (1%)
How Many People Are You - 1 (1%)
I Been Around - 1 (1%)
I'm Blue, I'm Lonesome - 1 (1%)
If You Need a Fool - 1 (1%)
Intro - 1 (1%)
Iron Man - 1 (1%)
Is This What You Wanted - 1 (1%)
Lengthwise - 1 (1%)
Letter to Jimmy Page - 1 (1%)
Life Saving Gun - 1 (1%)
Light Up Or Leave Me Alone - 1 (1%)
Lonely Trip - 1 (1%)
Manteca - 1 (1%)
Maple Leaf Rag - 1 (1%)
Mellow Mood - 1 (1%)
Mercenary Territory - 1 (1%)
Mercury - 1 (1%)
Middle of the Road - 1 (1%)
Mirror in the Bathroom - 1 (1%)
Most Events Aren't Planned - 1 (1%)
Mull - 1 (1%)
My Problem Right There - 1 (1%)
No Quarter - 1 (1%)
Nothing - 1 (1%)
O Canada - 1 (1%)
Oblivion - 1 (1%)
Oh Atlanta - 1 (1%)
Old Folks Boogie - 1 (1%)
On My Knees - 1 (1%)
Peaches en Regalia - 1 (1%)
Psycho Killer - 1 (1%)
Purple Rain - 1 (1%)
Ramble On - 1 (1%)
Ride Captain Ride - 1 (1%)
Rock 'n' Roll Suicide - 1 (1%)
Rocket in My Pocket - 1 (1%)
Round Room - 1 (1%)
Sailin' Shoes - 1 (1%)
Secret Smile - 1 (1%)
Shipwreck - 1 (1%)
Sigma Oasis - 1 (1%)
Sing Monica - 1 (1%)
Smoke on the Water Jam - 1 (1%)
Something - 1 (1%)
Spanish Moon - 1 (1%)
Sparks - 1 (1%)
Spooky - 1 (1%)
Spread It 'Round - 1 (1%)
Stairway to Heaven - 1 (1%)
Strawberry Letter 23 - 1 (1%)
Susskind Hotel - 1 (1%)
Tela - 1 (1%)
Thank You - 1 (1%)
The Birds - 1 (1%)
The Chinese Water Torture - 1 (1%)
The Haunted House - 1 (1%)
The Inlaw Josie Wales - 1 (1%)
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday - 1 (1%)
The Rover - 1 (1%)
The Unsafe Bridge - 1 (1%)
The Very Long Fuse - 1 (1%)
The Well - 1 (1%)
Things People Do - 1 (1%)
Timber - 1 (1%)
Time Loves a Hero - 1 (1%)
Tower Jam - 1 (1%)
Tripe Face Boogie - 1 (1%)
Two Versions of Me - 1 (1%)
Uncle Pen - 1 (1%)
Weigh - 1 (1%)
What's Going Through Your Mind - 1 (1%)
What's the Use? - 1 (1%)
Whole Lotta Love - 1 (1%)
Willin' - 1 (1%)
Wipe Out - 1 (1%)
Wombat - 1 (1%)

First Set Openers

Punch You in the Eye - 6
AC/DC Bag - 5
The Moma Dance - 4
Kill Devil Falls - 3
Buried Alive - 2
Chalk Dust Torture - 2
Down with Disease - 2
First Tube - 2
Fluffhead - 2
Free - 2
Heavy Things - 2
Mike's Song - 2
Runaway Jim - 2
Sample in a Jar - 2
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 2
The Wedge - 2
Tweezer - 2
Wilson - 2
Alumni Blues - 1
Carolina - 1
Cathy's Clown - 1
Cities - 1
Crowd Control - 1
Daniel Saw the Stone - 1
David Bowie - 1
Frankenstein - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
Garden Party - 1
Ghost - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Grind - 1
Gumbo - 1
Ha Ha Ha - 1
Harry Hood - 1
Martian Monster - 1
My Soul - 1
O Canada - 1
Reba - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Rocky Top - 1
The Sloth - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
Tube - 1
Walls of the Cave - 1
We Are Come to Outlive Our Brains - 1
Your Pet Cat - 1

First Set Closers

Walls of the Cave - 9
Character Zero - 6
Run Like an Antelope - 6
Julius - 4
Split Open and Melt - 4
David Bowie - 3
46 Days - 2
Bathtub Gin - 2
Cavern - 2
Fluffhead - 2
More - 2
Possum - 2
Rock and Roll - 2
Wolfman's Brother - 2
About to Run - 1
Birds of a Feather - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1
Fire - 1
First Tube - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Good Times Bad Times - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Harry Hood - 1
If I Could - 1
My Soul - 1
No Men In No Man's Land - 1
Quinn the Eskimo (The Mighty Quinn) - 1
Stash - 1
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 1
Suzy Greenberg - 1
Taste - 1
The Curtain With - 1
The Rover - 1
The Squirming Coil - 1
The Star-Spangled Banner - 1
Walk Away - 1
Weekapaug Groove - 1
You Enjoy Myself - 1

Second Set Openers

Down with Disease - 11
Tweezer - 6
Chalk Dust Torture - 4
Birds of a Feather - 3
Rock and Roll - 3
Wilson - 3
A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing - 2
Crosseyed and Painless - 2
Golden Age - 2
Punch You in the Eye - 2
Set Your Soul Free - 2
AC/DC Bag - 1
Also Sprach Zarathustra - 1
Axilla - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Buried Alive - 1
Character Zero - 1
Cool Amber and Mercury - 1
Drowned - 1
Everything's Right - 1
Evolve - 1
Fat Man in the Bathtub - 1
Funky Bitch - 1
Ghost - 1
Glide - 1
Golgi Apparatus - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Halley's Comet - 1
Intro - 1
Julius - 1
Lengthwise - 1
Mellow Mood - 1
Mike's Song - 1
No Men In No Man's Land - 1
Oblivion - 1
Party Time - 1
Possum - 1
Roses Are Free - 1
Runaway Jim - 1
Sand - 1
Scents and Subtle Sounds - 1
Steam - 1
The Wedge - 1
Tube - 1
Water in the Sky - 1

Second Set Closers

You Enjoy Myself - 10
David Bowie - 7
Slave to the Traffic Light - 7
Run Like an Antelope - 5
Character Zero - 4
Loving Cup - 4
Cavern - 3
First Tube - 2
Fluffhead - 2
Harry Hood - 2
Llama - 2
Possum - 2
Sand - 2
Suzy Greenberg - 2
Weekapaug Groove - 2
46 Days - 1
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Bug - 1
Chalk Dust Torture - 1
Drift While You're Sleeping - 1
Everything's Right - 1
Feats Don't Fail Me Now - 1
Ghost - 1
Good Times Bad Times - 1
Joy - 1
Martian Monster - 1
Most Events Aren't Planned - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Split Open and Melt - 1
The Squirming Coil - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1
Twist - 1
Waste - 1

Third Set Openers

46 Days - 1
Cavern - 1
Character Zero - 1
Down with Disease - 1
Meatstick - 1
My Soul - 1
No Men In No Man's Land - 1
Party Time - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Rock and Roll - 1
Twist - 1

Third Set Closers

You Enjoy Myself - 2
Backwards Down the Number Line - 1
Bug - 1
First Tube - 1
Fluffhead - 1
Friday - 1
Grind - 1
Lawn Boy - 1
Run Like an Antelope - 1
Tweezer Reprise - 1

Fourth Set Openers

Tower Jam - 1

Fourth Set Closers

Tower Jam - 1

Encores

Tweezer Reprise - 16
Rock and Roll - 6
First Tube - 5
Harry Hood - 5
Character Zero - 4
Loving Cup - 4
Show of Life - 4
Sleeping Monkey - 4
A Day in the Life - 3
Bug - 3
Cavern - 3
Golgi Apparatus - 3
Good Times Bad Times - 3
Slave to the Traffic Light - 3
Suzy Greenberg - 3
The Squirming Coil - 3
Tube - 3
Wading in the Velvet Sea - 3
Bold As Love - 2
Bouncing Around the Room - 2
Fee - 2
Frankenstein - 2
Grind - 2
Possum - 2
Run Like an Antelope - 2
Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. - 2
While My Guitar Gently Weeps - 2
A Life Beyond The Dream - 1
Boogie On Reggae Woman - 1
Carini - 1
Dog Log - 1
Driver - 1
Farmhouse - 1
Free Bird - 1
Gotta Jibboo - 1
Guyute - 1
Halley's Comet - 1
I Didn't Know - 1
Iron Man - 1
Is This What You Wanted - 1
Joy - 1
Julius - 1
Punch You in the Eye - 1
Rock 'n' Roll Suicide - 1
Rocky Top - 1
Sample in a Jar - 1
Saw It Again - 1
Shine a Light - 1
Something - 1
The Lizards - 1
The Mango Song - 1
The Sloth - 1
Waste - 1
Wipe Out - 1

10 20 30 40 50 most common songs that were not played in the band's history from your first year

Underplayed/Overplayed Songs since 1997

Expected versions is "percentage of shows the song was played in times number of shows seen" (eg if You Enjoy Myself were played in half of all shows and you have seen 20 shows, you would be "expected" to see 10 versions). These are the songs that you've seen the most above and below expectations. This section goes out to Amanda Wilson who inspired me to write it by seeing "Farmhouse" in each of her first 4 shows.

Underplayed

Overplayed

The 50% club

Longest Existing Gaps

Debut Count

You saw 49 song debuts
0.66 debuts per show.
The most frequently played song you have seen debuted is Kill Devil Falls (124 times).

Sort by Earliest debuted Most often played

Hiatus Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-hiatus songs that have not been seen since:

Dogs Stole Things - 2
Ginseng Sullivan - 2
Albuquerque - 1
Been Caught Stealing - 1
Billy Breathes - 1
Buffalo Bill - 1
Crossroads - 1
Free Bird - 1
Have Mercy - 1
I'm Blue, I'm Lonesome - 1

Most frequently seen post-hiatus songs that were not seen before:

Rock and Roll - 19
46 Days - 15
Kill Devil Falls - 15
Slave to the Traffic Light - 15
The Wedge - 15
Ocelot - 14
Backwards Down the Number Line - 12
NICU - 12
Light - 11
Sand - 11

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the hiatus are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post hiatus

Biggest increase post hiatus

Breakup Song Breakdown

Most frequently seen pre-breakup songs that have not been seen since:

Dog Log - 2
Dogs Stole Things - 2
Ginseng Sullivan - 2
Jam - 2
Albuquerque - 1
All of These Dreams - 1
Anything But Me - 1
Been Caught Stealing - 1
Billy Breathes - 1
Buffalo Bill - 1

Most frequently seen post-breakup songs that were not seen before:

Kill Devil Falls - 15
Slave to the Traffic Light - 15
Ocelot - 14
Backwards Down the Number Line - 12
Light - 11
Sand - 11
Suzy Greenberg - 11
Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan - 9
Divided Sky - 8
Heavy Things - 8

Percentage Differences

To keep this interesting, only songs that have been seen both before and after the breakup are included in this list. Expected versions is what you would have seen if the percentages remained constant

Biggest drop off post breakup

Biggest increase post breakup

First/Last Time Seen